Sales Representatives

The Ohio Plan was formed in 1988 and five agencies have been a part of the Ohio Plan’s success since it first began. These five founding agents are:

V.S. Beck Insurance, Inc.

120 N. Defiance St.
Archbold, OH 43502

877-446-BECK
419-446-2777

Established in 1948 by Vincent S. Beck, our company has grown to a full service insurance agency. V.S. Beck Insurance Agency serves the insurance needs of many individuals, families, businesses and governmental entities throughout Northwest Ohio.

Kinder’s Insurance

223 S. 4th St.
P.O. Box 128
Ironton, OH 45638

740-532-3323

Kinder’s Insurance Agency, Ltd. was founded in 1970 by Bernard Kinder. In 1986, Mr. Kinder established the first insurance pool in Ohio for county governments. The agency has since specialized in insuring public entities which include counties, cities, villages, townships, water and sewer districts, as well as fire and EMS districts for all lines of coverage.

Love Insurance Agency

34920 Ridge Rd., Suite 100
Willoughby, OH 44094

877-859-3073

The people at Love Insurance Agency have over 100 years of expertise in handling public insurance and risk management for cities, townships, villages, schools, counties, fire departments and special districts. Operating as an independent insurance agency, Love Insurance Agency has been growing since 1950, evolving to meet the increasingly complex and demanding needs of its clients.

Rinehart, Walters, Danner & Associates

446 Park Ave., West
Mansfield, OH 44906

800-837-9969
419-522-9892

Since 1956, Rinehart, Walters, Danner and Associates has been a hidden asset for many business and governmental entities throughout Ohio – structuring innovative insurance solutions for our clients. As an independent insurance agency, we represent a number of well-known, financially sound companies that expect their representatives to meet the highest professional standards.

Whitaker-Myers Group

3524 Commerce Parkway
Wooster, OH 44691

800-950-1869

At Whitaker-Myers, we’re big enough to understand our clients and to have access to essential markets, but we’re small enough to maintain that local, independent agent feeling. Closely held, over 150 years old, more than 30 associates strong and specializing in managing risk for public entities of all kinds and sizes, we offer our clients a multi-disciplined approach, with practices in commercial and personal insurance, employee benefit plans, and wealth management. We’re the WHITAKER-MYERS Group, since 1869 – with offices in Wooster, Ashland and Mansfield.

Over the years, the Ohio Plan has appointed the following additional agencies throughout the state of Ohio:

Gardner Parker Insurance

803 W Taylor St.
P.O. Box 3178
Zanesville, OH 43702

740-452-2656

Gardner Parker Insurance, founded in 1939, has grown to a full-service agency writing property and casualty coverage as well as group medical, life and ancillary products. John D. Parker, the principal agent, serves Muskingum and the contiguous counties.

Hylant Administrative Services

811 Madison Ave.
11th Floor
Toledo, OH 43604

800-249-5268

Hylant Administrative Services was created in 1994 and has provided creative insurance solutions for the public entity sector ever since. We pride ourselves on our commitment to public schools and public entities and remain committed to the public sector.

Hylant

Summit Woods Corporate Center
50 E Business Way, Suite 420
Cincinnati, OH 45241

888-985-2400

Hylant’s growth over the past 80 years is the result of dedicated employees, a commitment to community enrichment and versatile product lines. With over 550 employees, we assure our clients confidence, stability and value. Our clients include both public and private entities and both for-profit and nonprofit organizations.

Ratermann Insurance Agency

311 North Main St.
Fort Loramie, OH 45845

937-295-2131

Ratermann Insurance was founded by Adolph F. Ratermann in 1904. In that year he became licensed with the Michigan Mutual Life Insurance Company and began to sell their life products. Later he was an agent for the Midland Mutual Life Insurance Company and in 1937 became an agent for Motorists Mutual Insurance Company. Adolph continued to work in the insurance business until his death in 1950.

Ruese Insurance Agency

100 S. Main Ave.
Suite 200
Sidney, OH 45365

937-498-4586

Established in 1886, Ruese Insurance Group has become one of the most respected insurance agencies in west central Ohio. We specialize in commercial, governmental, automotive and homeowners insurance. You may not usually think about insurance until you need it. That’s why we make it our job to make sure you are covered when that time comes. We take the time to sit down with you, face to face, to thoroughly go over your insurance needs and answer any questions you may have.

Schwendeman Agency, Inc.

109 Putnam St.
Marietta, OH 45750

800-837-6793

The Schwendeman Agency, Inc. was established in Marietta, Ohio, in 1929. We have a rich history and are proud to be an independent, third generation family business. Our independent status allows us to faithfully serve our clients’ best interests through our powerfully diverse network of insurance carriers. The agency specializes in the placement and management of comprehensive insurance portfolios for schools, colleges, municipal risks, public entities and nonprofits.

Smith-Feike-Minton, Inc.

2333 Rombach Ave.
Wilmington, OH 45177

937-382-2546

Headquartered in Wilmington, Ohio, Smith-Feike-Minton, Inc. (SFM) combines the objectivity of an independent insurance agency with the personal care and local knowledge to fully serve its customers. Serving clients in business, government and personal lines, the team of insurance experts at SFM protects the security of the people who trust them, using innovative ideas to design plans that employ the best practices to the benefit of their clients.

Stapleton Insurance Group

7250 Crossleigh Court
P.O. Box 1118
Sylvania, OH 43560

419-720-OHIO (6446)

Founded in 1927, Stapleton Insurance Group is a privately held insurance firm offering a broad array of property and casualty, employee benefits, surety, risk management and compliance services throughout Northwest Ohio and Southeastern Michigan. We help our clients tackle the business issues they face today through teamwork, passion and integrity.

Stolly Insurance Group

1730 Allentown Rd.
P.O. Box 5067
Lima, OH 45802

800-686-2147

The Stolly Insurance Group has been operating as an independent insurance agency since 1904. Family directed values have prompted a reputation of honesty, integrity and professional excellence. We strive to provide long-lasting solutions through a wide range of insurance and financial products. Our approach continues to represent new ideas and methods of problem solving, while being communicated in a personable manner.

The Edward H. Sutton Insurance Agency, Inc.

12 South Chillicothe Rd.
P.O. Box 271
Aurora, OH 44202

330-562-5145

The E. H. Sutton Insurance Agency, Inc. is a three-generation family business located in Aurora, Ohio. The agency was founded in 1935 by Edward H. Sutton and is currently operated by son, Benjamin T. Sutton and grandson, Benjamin D. Sutton. Strategically located in the northwest corner of Portage County, the agency borders on Cuyahoga, Geauga and Summit Counties and draws its business from this extensive four-county region.

Scroll to Top